Home / Reviews / A House on the Hill

Cover of A House on the Hill by Eleanor Birney
Historical fictionMystery and thrillerVictorianHistorical mystery

A House on the Hill

Book
4 · Good with weak spots
Herbal
0 · None
Spice
0 · Clean, closed door

For fans of A Birdcage Library, Outlander, Murder With Peacocks

A House on the Hill is book 2 in Eleanor Birney's Green Baize Door Mystery series, a Victorian historical mystery coming out January 27, 2027.

I loved the mystery, the plot and the atmosphere of this one. The pace kept me eager to uncover what was really going on, and the historical setting felt rich and real the whole way through. There is a wide range of characters and personalities, and the ending surprised me!

My one hesitation is the love story. It was sweet, but it is only a small part of the book.

🌿0 for herbalism connection. Opium and arsenic both appear in the story, opium as a pain reliever and arsenic as a poison, and both are used accurately for the time.

Thank you to Parlor & Dock Press and NetGalley for the advance copy. All opinions are my own.

Tropes include: he falls first, age gap, strong female lead, twist ending and poisoner.

If you loved A Birdcage Library, Outlander, Murder With Peacocks, this is for you.

Content warnings: sexual assault or rape, attempted assault, coercion, sexual harassment, death of a parent or child, terminal illness, suicide or suicidal thoughts, infertility, drug use, racism.

The herbal connection

0 · None. Opium and arsenic are in the story. Opium is used as a pain reliever, arsenic as a poison.

Plants in the pages: Opium, Arsenic

Plant knowledge Accurate

The five things I judge

What I judgeHit or miss?Notes
PaceMostly hitGood pace, I was eager to uncover the mystery but also loved the historical feel
PlotHitGreat plot and surprise ending!
CharactersMostly hitA wide range of characters and personalities
Love storyMixedIt was a sweet story but a small section of the story
Herbal connectionLightAccurate historically